Opinion

Automation is a design requirement, not a bolt-on

I first came across Sandvik's underground automation technology during my bachelor's degree, in 2018. In 2023 I spent my master's thesis inside Sandvik's automation business working on AutoMine®, and the first thing it did was make some of the mines I had worked at feel almost neolithic.

The second thing it did was change how I think about automation. The question I now ask is not "which machine?" It is "was this mine designed to be automated?"

What the thesis was actually about

My thesis looked at the mine-design requirements for automated load and haul underground, limited to block caving and sublevel stoping. In practice that meant designing mine layouts, connectivity and control-room set-ups for simulation, and tracing how the geometry of the mine and the way people work shape what an automated system needs in order to perform.

That framing matters. Most conversations about automation start with the equipment: which OEM, which loader, which truck, which software. The machine is the visible part. But an autonomous loader does not run in a brochure. It runs in your drives, through your intersections, around your ore passes and drawpoints, under your ventilation and communications, and inside your rules for who is allowed where and when.

If those were designed for a manned fleet, the automated fleet inherits every compromise.

What I saw at full scale

During the thesis I visited El Teniente in Chile, one of the largest underground copper mines in the world, where automation runs at genuinely large scale. It was humbling. It also showed me the other half of the argument.

In a drawbell I saw a boulder hang-up: rock that should have flowed and did not. No algorithm predicts that particular boulder. Dealing with it takes people: someone has to recognise it, decide what to do and make it safe before production can carry on.

That is not a failure of automation. It is a reminder that a mine is a physical system that will keep producing surprises, and the design has to account for both the routine work the machines do well and the exceptions that still need people.

Cost it like a system

Before Sandvik I spent time in technical services at Boliden's Garpenberg mine in Sweden, building a costed study of ore-transport automation options. We compared different OEM pathways using haulage simulations and supplier quotations.

What I took from it was simple. Automation options look very different once you cost them as a system rather than as equipment. The machines are one line. The layout changes, the infrastructure, the traffic management, the people and the transition from the way the mine runs today are the rest. A cheaper machine that needs the mine rebuilt around it is not a cheaper option.

Getting people out of the danger zone

I have sat at the operator stations of the future for drilling and load and haul. Whatever your view on automation, putting the operator in a quiet, cool room away from the face and the production zone is hard to argue against. That is the strongest case for automation, and it does not need any inflated productivity claim to stand up.

But the people do not disappear. They move. Their job becomes supervising the system, handling exceptions and deciding when the machine should stop. A control room laid out as an afterthought, or a workflow nobody designed, wastes that.

The same lesson for AI

I now work on what I call Mining AI: using AI to organise evidence and support decisions on mining projects. The lesson carries straight across.

An AI tool is not a bolt-on either. It works when the work around it is designed for it: clean, traceable inputs, a clear question, a person who checks the output and a defined point where a human makes the call. It struggles when it is dropped on top of messy data and an undefined process and expected to fix both. Then it just produces confident answers faster.

So my view, for underground fleets and for AI alike:

  • Design for it from the start. Layout, data, workflow and people should be planned with the automated system in mind, not adapted afterwards.
  • Cost the whole system. Equipment or software is one line in a longer list.
  • Plan for exceptions. The hang-up, the bad record, the edge case. Decide in advance who handles it and how.
  • Keep a human accountable. Automation moves people out of harm's way and away from routine work. It does not remove the need for judgement.

The technology is real and it is getting better. The mines and projects that benefit most from it will be the ones designed to use it, not the ones that buy it and hope.

← Back to insights